No. 02-3482

________________________

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

________________________

ROBERT A. NEINAST,
Plaintiff - Appellant,

v.

BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE COLUMBUS METROPOLITAN
LIBRARY; LARRY D. BLACK, Director; VONZELL L. JOHNSON,
Assistant Manager, Security,
Defendants - Appellees.

________________________

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO, EASTERN DIVISION

________________________

JOINT APPENDIX

________________________



  Robert A. Neinast
Plaintiff, PRO SE
8617 Ashford Lane
Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 759-1601
Email: neinast@worldnet.att.net




TABLE OF CONTENTS


Since the briefing schedule contains no provision for a "proof" brief, each reference in the Briefs to the Joint Appendix contains a "Reference Number." To assist the Court in finding the referenced items, the Joint Appendix contains, immediately following, and part of the Table of Contents, a Cross-Reference Table, providing a linkage between the references in the briefs and the Joint Appendix page numbers. The Index to Cross-References begins on page (vi).


Index to Joint Appendix (Volume I)
Description Docket Number Location in Appendix
District Docket Sheet - Page 1
(Tab A)
Complaint - Page 5
(Tab B)
Amended Complaint 8 Page 12
(Tab C)
Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment, pp. 16-17, 21-25 13 Page 21
(Tab D)
Judgment 19 Page 28
(Tab E)
Order and Opinion 18 Page 29
(Tab F)
Notice of Appeal 20 Page 45
(Tab G)
Larry Black Affidavit (Def. Motion, Exhibit A) 11 Page 46
(Tab H)
Library Organization Policy (Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 1) 11 Page 49
(Tab H)
Eviction Procedure (Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 2) 11 Page 50
(Tab H)
December 14, 2000 letter from David Swaddling to Robert Neinast (Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 3) 11 Page 55
(Tab H)
February 12, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Robert Neinast, with enclosure by Jeffrey Glasgow (Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 4) 11 Page 56
(Tab H)
Robert Neinast Affidavit (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1) 13 Page 59
(Tab I)
Letter from Ohio Department of Health (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment A) 13 Page 66
(Tab I)
Letter from Franklin County District Board of Health (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment B) 13 Page 67
(Tab I)
Letter from Columbus Health Department (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment C) 13 Page 68
(Tab I)
Library Mission Statement (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment G) 13 Page 69
(Tab I)
March 5, 2001 letter from Robert Neinast to Larry Black (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment J) 13 Page 70
(Tab I)
March 12, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Robert Neinast (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment K) 13 Page 72
(Tab I)
Morgan Condo Affidavit (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 4) 13 Page 73
(Tab J)
Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories, pg. 2 (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6, pg. 2) 13 Page 74
(Tab K)
March 2, 2001 memo from Chris Taylor to Larry Black (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6, Attachment A, pg. 1) 13 Page 75
(Tab K)
Eviction Notice for Robert Neinast (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6, Attachment A, pg. 2) 13 Page 76
(Tab K)
1 Annals of Congress 759-760 (Gales & Seaton ed. 1834) (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 10) 13 Page 77
(Tab L)
"Footloose in San Francisco", San Francisco Chronicle (Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 11) 13 Page 79
(Tab M)
Incident Reports (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pp. 14, 27, 80, 112, 158, 202) 14 Page 80
(Tab N)
Patron Regulations Policy (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 82) 14 Page 86
(Tab O)
Eviction Procedure (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93) 14 Page 87
(Tab P)
December 11, 2000 letter from Robert Neinast to David Swaddling, with Attachments (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 99) 14 Page 90
(Tab Q)
January 30, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Jeff Glasgow, Ass't Franklin County Prosecutor (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 97) 14 Page 94
(Tab R)
Order and Amended Order from Kreimer v. Bureau of Police, 765 F.Supp 181 (D.N.J. 1991) (Pla. Reply, Exhibit 4) 15 Page 95
(Tab S)



Table of Transcripts (Volume I)
Description Transcript Page Number Location in Appendix
Transcript of Oral Argument, held February 22, 2002, before the Honorable Algenon L. Marbley 1 Page 99
(Tab T)



Index to Joint Appendix (Volume II)
Description Docket Number Appendix Page Number
Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First and Second Sets of Interrogatories (Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, all pages) 14 Page 119



Index of Cross-References (Brief of Appellant)
Reference Number in Briefs Location in Appendix Description
1 Page 59
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 1, ¶ 1
2 Page 63
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 5, ¶ 12
3 Page 63
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 5, ¶ 14
4 Page 64
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 6, ¶ 15
5 Page 64
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 6, ¶ 16
6 Page 86
(Tab O) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 82 (Patron Regulations Policy)
7 Page 87
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93 (Eviction Procedure, p. 3)
8 Pages 90-93
(Tab Q) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 99-102 (December 11, 2000 letter from Robert Neinast to David Swaddling, with Attachments)
9 Page 55
(Tab H) 		Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 3 (December 14, 2000 letter from David Swaddling to Robert Neinast)
10 Page 49
(Tab H) 		Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 1 (Library Organization Policy), pg. 1
11 Page 94
(Tab R) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 97 (January 30, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Jeff Glasgow, Ass't Franklin County Prosecutor)
12 Page 56
(Tab H) 		Def. Motion, Exhibit A, Attachment 4 (February 12, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Robert Neinast, with enclosure by Jeffrey Glasgow)
13 Page 70
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment J (March 5, 2001 letter from Robert Neinast to Larry Black)
14 Page 72
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment K (March 12, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Robert Neinast)
15 Page 73
(Tab J) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 4 (Morgan Condo Affidavit)
16 Page 66
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment A (Letter from Ohio Department of Health)
17 Page 67
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment B (Letter from Franklin County District Board of Health)
18 Page 68
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment C (Letter from Columbus Health Department)
19 Page 74
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), pg. 2
20 Pages 87-89
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93-95 (Eviction Procedure, pp. 3-5)
21 Page 63
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 5, ¶ 12
22 Page 65
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 7, ¶¶ 19-20
23 Page 74
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), pg. 2
24 Page 64
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 6, ¶¶ 15-16
25 Page 87
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93 (Eviction Procedure, pg. 3)
26 Page 76
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), Attachment A, pg. 2 (Eviction Notice for Robert Neinast)
27 Page 62
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 4, ¶ 9
28 Page 63
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 5, ¶ 11
29 Page 22
(Tab D) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, pg. 17 (Discussion of bare feet and wet floors)
30 Page 62
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 4, ¶ 10
31 Page 33
(Tab F) 		Order and Opinion, pg. 5
32 Page 80
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, pg. 14 (Incident Report)
33 Page 81
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, pg. 27 (Incident Report)
34 Page 83
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, pg. 112 (Incident Report)
35 Page 105
(Tab T) 		Oral Arg. Transcript, pg. 7
36 Page 84
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, pg. 158 (Incident Report)
37 Page 82
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 80 (Incident Report)
38 Page 21
(Tab D) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, pg. 16 (Discussion that shoe policy does not apply outside)
39 Page 64
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 6, ¶ 15
40 Page 77
(Tab L) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 10 (1 Annals of Congress 759-760 (Gales & Seaton ed. 1834))
41 Page 79
(Tab M) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 11 ("Footloose in San Francisco", San Francisco Chronicle)
42 Pages 23-27
(Tab D) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, pp. 21-25 (Survey of cases addressing right of personal appearance)
43 Page 39
(Tab F) 		Order and Opinion, p. 11
44 Page 74
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), pg. 2
45 Page 87
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93 (Eviction Procedure, pg. 3)
46 Page 75
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), Attachment A, pg. 1 (March 2, 2001 memo from Chris Taylor to Larry Black)
47 Page 86
(Tab O) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 82 (Patron Regulations Policy)
48 Page 69
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment G (Library Mission Statement)


The Library declined Neinast's invitation that they provide Cross-Reference numbers in their Brief of Appellees. Therefore, there is no corresponding Index of Cross-Reference for that document.




Index of Cross-References (Reply Brief of Appellant)
Reference Number in Briefs Location in Appendix Description
49 Page 73
(Tab J) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 4 (Morgan Condo Affidavit)
50 Page 66
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment A (Letter from Ohio Department of Health)
51 Page 67
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment B (Letter from Franklin County District Board of Health)
52 Page 68
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment C (Letter from Columbus Health Department)
53 Page 60
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 2, ¶ 5
54 Page 47
(Tab H) 		Def. Motion, Exhibit A (Larry Black Affidavit), ¶ 10
55 Page 94
(Tab R) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 97 (January 30, 2001 letter from Larry Black to Jeff Glasgow, Ass't Franklin County Prosecutor)
56 Page 46
(Tab H) 		Def. Motion, Exhibit A (Larry Black Affidavit), ¶¶ 3-5
57 Page 87
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93 (Eviction Procedure, p. 3)
58 Page 65
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), pg. 7, ¶¶ 19-20
59 Page 74
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), pg. 2
60 Page 95
(Tab S) 		Pla. Reply, Exhibit 4 (Order and Amended Order from Kreimer v. Bureau of Police, 765 F.Supp 181 (D.N.J. 1991))
61 Page 77
(Tab L) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 10 (1 Annals of Congress 759-760 (Gales & Seaton ed. 1834))
62 Page 59
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1 (Robert Neinast Affidavit), ¶ 3
63 Page 107
(Tab T) 		Oral Arg. Transcript, pg. 9
64 Page 109
(Tab T) 		Oral Arg. Transcript, pg. 11
65 Page 85
(Tab N) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 202 (Incident Report)
66 Pages 87-89
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 93-95 (Eviction Procedure, pp. 3-5)
67 Page 86
(Tab O) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 82 (Patron Regulations Policy)
68 Page 89
(Tab P) 		Def. Reply and Memo. Contra, Appendix, Exhibit A, pg. 95 (Eviction Procedure, p. 5)
69 Page 70
(Tab I) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 1, Attachment J (March 5, 2001 letter from Robert Neinast to Larry Black)
70 Page 75
(Tab K) 		Pla. Motion and Memo. Contra, Exhibit 6 (Defendants' Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories), Attachment A, pg. 1 (March 2, 2001 memo from Chris Taylor to Larry Black)


CERTIFICATION OF DOCUMENT


I hereby certify that all documents included in this Joint Appendix are copies of documents properly made part of the record.



  ___________________________
Robert A. Neinast




CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE


I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing was served, by regular U.S. mail, upon Philomena M. Dane and Johnathan E. Sullivan, Attorneys for Defendants, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, L.L.P., 1300 Huntington Center, 41 South High Street, Columbus, OH, 43215, this 22nd day of June, 2002.



  ___________________________
Robert A. Neinast